Alpha Lipoic Acid Benefits and Side Effects - Vitacost

Alpha Lipoic Acid
By Allen S. Josephs, M.D.
President, Vitacost

Jefferson Medical College, Board Certified in Internal Medicine & Board Certified in Neurology, Section Chief, Neurology, St. Barnabas Hospital, Livingston, NJ


We submitted four different alpha lipoic acid products for independent lab analysis to Alpha Laboratories. The products were from the better manufacturers, including Solgar, TwinLab, Natrol and Nutraceutical Sciences Institute (NSI).

Research in the last decade has strongly implicated oxidative damage within the cells, caused by free radicals, as the cause of many of the degenerative disorders of aging. Included in this group is Alzheimer's disease, Parkinson's, arthritis, cancer, heart disease and a host of other conditions. Studies have shown that oxidative damage is seen throughout various portions of the brain cells in Alzheimer's patients. Anti-oxidants have been shown in numerous studies to halt or reduce oxidative damage in cells and, in many cases, stabilize and even reverse the cell damage. There have been multiple studies in the medical literature indicating that anti-oxidants such as vitamin C and vitamin E can have beneficial effects in slowing down and perhaps even reducing the likelihood of developing Alzheimer's disease, Parkinson's, etc.

A little known but extremely powerful antioxidant nutrient is available in supplemental form called alpha lipoic acid. It is a vitamin-like substance that contains sulfur. Alpha lipoic acid (ALA) plays an extremely important role in energy production within the cell. What makes alpha lipoic acid so effective as an anti-oxidant is that it works on both water and fat soluble free radicals which are the cause of oxidation.

For those of you who think that alpha lipoic acid (ALA) is a nutrient that has not been well researched, think again. A recent Medline search indicated 1,378 articles in the medical literature on alpha lipoic acid. Alpha lipoic acid appears to be a wonder nutrient. It seems to work particularly well in diabetic patients. Experimental studies show that it has a potential renal protective effect. In a study out of Germany published last year, diabetic patients treated with 600 mg. of ALA daily had stabilization in urinary albumin concentration over an 18 month follow-up whereas patients in the control group had an increase in urinary albumin excretion. In animal studies the renal protective effects of ALA were not attributable to improved glycemic control alone but also likely related to its antioxidant activity. Alpha lipoic acid increases glucose uptake in the cells and appears to reduce symptoms of diabetic complications including cataract formation, vascular damage and even polyneuropathy (nerve damage). In a study published in the journal Diabetic Medicine from 1999, those patients treated with 600 mg. of ALA, three times daily for 3 weeks had improvement of diabetic symptoms from polyneuropathy. In another study using 600 to 1,800 mg of ALA daily those individuals treated were found to have improvement of insulin sensitivity. In animal studies it has been found to reduce oxidative DNA damage within heart cells.

More recent experimental studies have shown that ALA can actually reverse the damage in aging cells of the brain. This was a study published in the prestigious journal Proceedings of the National Academy of science from February of this year. In the study, aging rats were treated with either acetyl-L carnitine or ALA. Both of these nutrients improved performance in memory tasks by lowering oxidative damage and improving mitochondrial function. Electron microscopic studies of the brains of these animals indicated these nutrients reversed age associated mitochondrial structural decay. Alpha lipoic acid has also been used both in oral and topical form as a treatment for keeping skin healthy and young in appearance. There have been studies in the medical literature indicating that supplemental ALA can even be beneficial in patients with glaucoma.

Most studies have used 600-1,800 mg per day of alpha lipoic acid for optimal benefits in people with specific health concerns. If you are healthy and want to promote optimal health, a dose of 30 - 300 mg per day may be sufficient. Beware of products that contain 500 mcg (1/2 mg)-10 mg; these doses are probably too little to provide any benefit.

References:
Diabetes Res Clin Pract 2001 Jun;52(3):175-83
J Am Soc Nephrol 2002 Jan;13(1):108-16
Diabet Med 1999 Dec;16(12):1040-3
Free Radic Biol Med 1999 Aug;27(3-4):309-14
Free Radic Biol Med 1999 Nov;27(9-10):1114-21
FASEB J 2001 Mar;15(3):700-6
Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2002 Feb 19;99(4):2356-61

Scale 1-5
5-best, 1-worst
Ratings are based on the following criteria:
Superiority of nutrient levels
Expected Overall Effectiveness of the formulation
Safety of the formulation
Value compared to other similar products

NSI Alpha Lipoic Acid
Overall Rating: 5

Lab analysis indicates that a 300 mg capsule did, indeed, contained exactly 300 mg. The efficacy of this product would be considered superior because of the listed mg amount. The safety of this nutrient has been previously well established. The value of this formulation, however, far exceeds that of the other tested products. It calculates out to a total cost of $.83 per 1000 mg of alpha lipoic acid, clearly better than any of the other products tested with a cost savings of 39-58% when compared to other products.


Natrol Alpha Lipoic Acid
Overall Rating: 4.75

The lab analysis indicates that a 300 mg capsule contained 308 mg per capsule. The overall effectiveness of this formulation would be considered superior because of the full amount of the formulation that is present. The safety of this product has been well established.The cost per 1000 mg is $1.35.

Solgar Alpha Lipoic Acid
Overall Rating: 4.5

According to lab analysis a 200 mg capsule of Solgar contained 204 mg. This would make a superior formulation as noted above. The safety of this product has been previously indicated. However, Solgar's cost is more expensive at $1.95 per 1000 mg and is over twice as expensive as the NSI product.

TwinLab Alpha Lipoic Acid
Overall Rating: 4.5

According to the lab analysis a 100 mg capsule of TwinLab contained 105 mg. This would be considered to be a superior product in terms of effectiveness. The safety has been previously established. The cost, however, of this product is $1.83 per 1000 mg which makes it the most expensive of all products tested.

Vitacost, as a general rule, will remove any product from our shelves if it contains less than 90% of the amount listed on the label. We were pleased that all four products contained the exact amount or slightly more than the amount listed on the label.